Good: Medicaid work reporting gets a reprieve. Bad: The pause is voluntary...and still coming down the pike anyway
Yesterday I covered the half-dozen or so upcoming (or recently-enacted) changes to Medicaid eligibility and funding caused by the so-called "One Big Beautiful Bill Act" (OBBBA, aka the Big Ugly Bill). I deliberately left out the most controversial, impactful and well-known one which I promised to delve into today, so here goes: "Work Reporting Requirements."
It's important to note out of the gate that the Big Ugly Bill doesn't technically require anyone to work per se in order to remain eligible for Medicaid coverage; it requires them to report their working hours on a regular basis, and for those working hours to add up to 80 hours per month (effectively ~20 hours per week).
Let's first take another look at the actual requirements:
Under H.R. 1, states will be required to impose work requirements on working-age adults (ages 19 to 64) in states that have expanded eligibility for Medicaid coverage. Enrollees subject to work requirements must prove that they are performing 80 hours of work, or another approved activity, each month. The law exempts some Medicaid enrollees, including pregnant women, people with disabilities, and caregivers of dependent children under age 14.
Nationwide, work requirements will impact an estimated 18.5 million adults per year, who will have to regularly demonstrate compliance or prove that they qualify for an exemption. States must verify compliance both at the time an individual applies for Medicaid coverage and, once enrolled, at least every six months thereafter.
For people who don’t meet the reporting requirements, the state must issue a notice alerting them they are noncompliant. They then have 30 days to demonstrate compliance before their application is denied (if they are not yet enrolled in Medicaid) or they will be disenrolled from Medicaid. Individuals losing their Medicaid coverage for failure to meet the work requirement are also locked out of financial help to purchase coverage through the health insurance marketplaces.
Here's the official list of those who are exempt from the reporting requirements via my home state of Michigan's guidelines:
You are exempt if you are:
- Already subject to work requirements for food (SNAP) benefits.
- Already meeting work requirements for cash (TANF) benefits.
- Pregnant or gave birth within the past 12 months.
- A parent or caregiver of a child age 13 or under.
- A caregiver of a person(s) with a disability (someone who needs help with daily activities).
- An American Indian or Alaska Native (AI/AN).
- A person that was in foster care at age 18 and is currently younger than age 26.
- A disabled veteran.
- In a treatment program for a substance use disorder.
- In jail or prison now or in the past three months.
- A person with complex health needs, also referred to as medically frail.
IMPORTANT: In late October, there was a critical federal court ruling which struck down the Trump Regime's absurd definition of "medically frail," which limited this to those who were literally too sick to be able to physically comply...which would have included, for example:
“Cancer patients and survivors who are suffering from debilitating side effects of the disease or treatment would have to officially prove they can’t work, in a process that is likely to be difficult and take a long time,” Lisa Lacasse, the president of the ACS CAN, said in a statement. “Cancer patients who can still work — and many want to, for example, when they are well enough to work in between chemo rounds — will have to choose between losing their Medicaid coverage, working the required 80 hours per month, or giving up working altogether to qualify for an exemption.”
Thankfully, this definition has been struck down by the courts...except that the Trump Regime could still potentially appeal the decision.
Getting back to the list of exemptions...
- Living with a substance use disorder.
- Living with a physical, intellectual or developmental disability that makes it hard to do daily activities.
- Living with a mental health disorder.
- Living with a serious health condition that requires regular treatment.
- Experiencing temporary hardship, which is a short-term situation that may make it hard to work or complete other qualifying work activities. In these cases, you may not need to meet work requirements for a limited period of time. Temporary hardships include:
- Receiving care in a facility such as a hospital, nursing facility, psychiatric hospital, facility for people with intellectual disabilities, etc.
- Traveling outside of your community of residence for medical care for yourself or a dependent because it is not available in your community.
- Living in federally declared disaster areas.
- Living in an area with a high unemployment rate.
Of course, proving that you qualify for some of these exemptions can be quite the pain in the ass, especially the ones where your status changes over time (ie, pregnancy/birth, getting out of prison, completing a treatment program, etc). Every state is legally required to develop a tracking system for this.
Meanwhile, those who aren't exempt have several ways they can comply with the requirements:
Meet the minimum monthly income requirement:
You meet work requirements if you earn at least $580* in at least one month during the review period.
This includes all forms of earned income including jobs and self-employment. Make sure you report your job and all income on your application.
It's worth noting that $580/month is $7.25/hour...aka the federal minimum wage. Of course the minimum wage is higher in many states...as high as ~$17/hour or more in states like California, Connecticut, New York (City), Washington and the District of Columbia.
This means that you could work as little as 35 hours/month and still comply with the income requirement. Of course, if you're a single adult who earns more than $1,836/month ($22,025/year), you're no longer eligible to be enrolled in Medicaid via ACA expansion anyway. In states with ~$17/hr minimum wages, this effectively means that you're only eligible if you work between 35 - 107 hours per month.
Alternately, you can comply by...
Complete 80 hours of approved activities:
You can also meet work requirements by completing at least 80 hours of approved activities in one month during the review period.
Approved activities include:
- Paid or unpaid employment.
- Internship or work program.
- Volunteering or community service.
- Attending a high school or GED program.
- Attending a college or vocational program.
You can combine activities to reach 80 hours in a single month. You must report your activities and the number of hours completed.
Just as the exemption validation portion of the bill requires a whole new administrative system to be set up by each state, so do the reporting requirement provisions...and those are proving to be absurdly expensive:
...the work reporting requirements are complicated. The initial CMS guidance takes up three single-spaced pages just to summarize the statute. Among the many complexities are seven different pathways in which an individual who is not exempt from the requirement can demonstrate compliance, including having an income of at least $580 per month. States must have the operational capability to determine and verify compliance under each pathway, using an ex parte process where possible to minimize administrative burden on applicants and enrollees.
In addition, there are nine categories of individuals who are exempt from the work reporting requirement altogether, including individuals who are “medically frail or otherwise [have] special medical needs.” (States have the option of adding up to four additional exemptions). State Medicaid agencies must identify exempt individuals, verify that they are exempt, and ensure that they are not required to comply with the reporting requirements. And the agencies must do so both at application and, with respect to those enrolled in the program, every six months at renewal.
...The eligibility and enrollment systems of every one of the affected states will have to be extensively modified, if not completely overhauled, in order to operationalize these new requirements—i.e., determining who is subject to the requirements and who is not; determining and verifying exemptions; determining whether non-exempt individuals are in compliance and on what basis; and maintaining records documenting these determinations for purposes of CMS payment error rate measurement. In addition, states will likely have to expand eligibility staffing in order to process double the number of renewals each year.
There were several states which actually already had work reporting requirements in place for several months back during the first Trump Regime via Section 1115 waivers which were approved by the Trump Regime but later rescinded via various federal court orders (one of these, in Georgia, survived the court rulings). According to the General Accounting Office, it cost over $400 million for five of these states to partially implement these provisions in 2019, while Georgia spent $54 million alone in the first few years their program was in place.
While H.R.1 includes a requirement that the federal government cover a portion of the cost for various expenses in setting up these systems (design, development, installation, maintenance, administrative costs etc), it's still an absurd amount of money whose sole purpose is to verify that those receiving Medicaid are doing what the vast majority of them are already doing: 64% of adults on Medicaid already work full or part time, and another 28% are either caretakers for sick family members, are sick/disabled themselves, or attend school full or part time.
For example, according to this Politico article:
While the One Big Beautiful Bill Act included $200 million in federal funds to be divided between expansion states to help pay for implementation costs, several officials said it won’t be nearly enough to cover them.
North Carolina, for example, got $1.9 million in federal funding to implement the work requirements, but expects it will need to spend an estimated $31.2 million annually to enforce them and conduct the biannual eligibility checks Congress mandated.
...Pennsylvania Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro proposed a $7.8 million outlay to update the state’s IT systems before the 2027 deadline, on top of $6.5 million in federal grants the state is expecting to help with the tech upgrades.
Pennsylvania expects it needs to hire nearly 400 hundred people to implement the work requirements and other parts of the megabill.
...Ohio, meanwhile, estimates that it needs $28 million over two years for the work requirements to update systems, staff and outreach.
New Mexico estimates it will cost the state $24 million in state funds over 18 months to make changes to its Medicaid system and to include changes to the IT system for the SNAP food program.
It's not just about the cost, either; states have spent months scrambling to comply with establishing, testing & implementing the necessary system overhauls, and many of them have found that they simply won't be able to do so by the January deadline. In response to this, just a few days ago, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a 6-month deadline delay for states to get their ducks in a row:
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) today announced an optional hold harmless period through and including June 30, 2027, providing states a transition period to further modernize systems, improve processes, and streamline the applicant and beneficiary experience. States that implement the hold harmless period will assess whether individuals meet the work requirement or are excluded from it, but they will not deny applications or disenroll otherwise eligible individuals solely for failure to meet the requirement.
The optional hold harmless transition period gives states the ability to improve and refine their systems and processes before enforcement begins, supporting long-term success of the work requirement. It will also provide states the opportunity to learn from the early months of implementation to identify and address workforce training needs and improve the beneficiary experience.
So, the good news is that states have until July 1st, 2027 before they have to actually begin kicking people off their coverage.
The bad news is that this is an optional deadline extension only...which means states that want to (and are in a position to) start doing so sooner than July can still do so if they wish.
In fact, there are three states which already started implementing the new work reporting requirements earlier this year: Nebraska (way back in May), Montana and Arkansas (both in July).
So how has that gone so far?
Well, in Nebraska, the first state to ramp up the new requirements, the early indications aren't great:
Nebraska implemented the work requirements in May. Since the early rollout, the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has received over 11,389 applications that include this new requirement.
From those numbers, we found nearly 10 percent of new and renewed applications have been denied.
That's around 1,100 people either denied or losing Medicaid coverage in the first four months alone.
10% of the estimated 18.5 million Americans expected to be impacted by the new requirements would amount to at least an additional 1.85 million losting Medicaid coverage on top of the 6.4 million who had already lost it between January 2025 and July 2026.
I fact, last spring the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation estimated that between 4.9 - 10.1 million could lose coverage by 2028 due specifically to the new H.R.1 requirements. (note: RWJF is a sponsor of this website)
Nebraska resident Alexander Liu has battled through several medical conditions, including near-total vision loss, and immediate surgery for a brain tumor.
“It literally did save my life,” Liu said. “And I would not be here without Medicaid.”
...Liu said the new paperwork is hard to navigate.
“It's almost like straight, like legal jargon. It's so confusing,” Liu said. “Their lines and their call centers are so overwhelmed.”
...“Once you're kicked off, it's like it can be very, very difficult for you to get back on,” Liu said.
The confusion problems were also highlighted by another more recent story via KFF Health News just last week:
...the rollout in Nebraska — eight months earlier than the timeline required by law — has been rife with problems, according to health clinics and organizations advocating for poor and working-class Nebraskans.
The story of Eli McCreary shows how confusion has interrupted essential medical care. McCreary, who lives in Omaha, was diagnosed with kidney cancer earlier this year. Shortly after, he said, he got a call from a local hospital. He said he was informed that he wasn’t insured anymore under Medicaid — and that the hospital would cancel his appointments unless he paid out-of-pocket.
When McCreary, who was 64 at the time, phoned a call center for help, he said he was told his Medicaid now required him to have a job.
McCreary had previously worked as a driver for an asphalt services company before his health deteriorated. He said he’d worked “until I couldn’t do the job anymore.”
In McCreary's case, it turned out that he was misinformed: The actual reason he lost Medicaid coverage turned out to be because he had turned 65 and had to enroll in Medicare instead. He was able to do so and reschedule his appointments...but multiply his experience by millions of others and you start to get an idea what sort of chaos this could result in, especially for people already dealing with serious and often debilitating medical conditions.
(sigh) Democrats will take control of both the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate on January 3rd, 2027, and have made reversing the draconian Big Ugly Bill Medicaid cuts one of their top priorities...but of course even if they do so it will likely be vetoed by Donald Trump, so the next few years are still likely to be grim for millions of lower-income Americans currently on Medicaid.



